Summary
QRI5 means Qualitative
Reading Inventory and is a informal reading
inventory that has word lists and passages per the student’s grade level. QRI5 assess a student’s fluency with oral
and silent reading and listening skills and can be used from pre-k to high
school. It provides student data on identifying words and understanding text. The QRI-5 can help determine a student’s
independent, instructional and frustration level in reading.
DIBELS means Dynamic Indicators are a set of Basic Early Literacy Skills. It is a five minute assessment procedures.
DIBELS evaluates alphabetic principle, phonological and phonemic awareness,
comprehension, vocabulary, accuracy and fluency with text. Using this tool
helps teachers to monitor the development of literacy skills. This tool can be used to identify students
that need additional instruction to prevent the student from being a struggling
reader
Similarities
Like DIBELS, QRI5 provides assessment options. Both
evaluate a students’ comprehension and fluency. Each test measures a students’
miscues in reading. Both evaluates a students reading abilities. Information
from both can be used by teachers to design differentiation for the student.
Differences
Unlike DIBELS that
measure from 1-6. QRI5 measures from 1 to high school levels. DIBELS is a
faster tool to use to assess a students reading level. DIBELS also is a shorter
test in comparison to QRI5. QRI5 rates students
according to their reading levels independent and instructional. QRI5 does not identify if the student
demonstrates difficulty with phonics or phonemes QRI5 can be used as a
preventative method for students showing signs as being a struggling reader.
Instructional planning and Decisions
DIBELS and QRI5 provides information on students for
teachers to focus on certain areas for instructional planning. Knowing the
strengths and weaknesses of students allows teachers to emphasize more time on
certain areas. These assessment tools provides teachers crucial information in
creating IEP’s for struggling students.
The DIBELS test can be used to inform the teacher of the early literacy needs
of a student. This allows the teacher to focus on the areas the student needs
help. The data from the test can help a teacher design a lesson in the areas
the student demonstrates need. The QRI5 provides essential information for the
teacher to create an intervention strategy to help the areas the student
demonstrates need.